Our Passion for

Cakes

Here at Bake Me Treats we believe in the power of CAKE. A party needs cake, and we are here to make it for you. We strive to make beautiful cakes; looks are not all the matters though! Taste is key. All of our cakes, fillings, and buttercreams are made from scratch, in house. We believe in perfecting our process and making sure that everything we offer is absolutely delicious. Below our BMT Short Stack Cakes and BMT Signature Cakes are listed. They consist of cake, filling, and buttercream combinations that we are truly thrilled to serve. Each cake flavor has a set decoration. Take a look further below to see each option.

Pre-Order Information
We require a 50% deposit on all orders over $30. Orders must be finalized by our preorder deadlines listed below or order will be canceled.
Tuesday-Thursday pickups: the preceding Saturday at 4:00 p.m.
Friday and Saturday pickups: the preceding Tuesday at 5:00 p.m.

Cancellation Information
Deposits will be retained if orders are canceled after our cancelation deadlines listed below.
Tuesday-Thursday pickups: the preceding Saturday at 4:00 p.m.
Friday and Saturday pickups: the preceding Tuesday at 5:00 p.m.

Cake Menu and Prices

Cake Size

4”
6”
8”
10”
1/4 Sheet

Serves up to

4-6
10-16
12-20
18-26
16-20

Short Stacks

$20
$35
$50
$70
$65

BMT Signature

$25
$45
$65
$80
N/A

BMT Short
Stack Cakes

All Short Stacks available in Tiered Cake options.

Classic White

white cake with vanilla buttercream

Classic Chocolate

chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream

Lovely Lemon

lemon cake filled with lemon curd, frosted with white buttercream

The Happiest Birthday

funfetti cake filled and frosted with white buttercream

Blueberries and Cream

blueberry cake filled with blueberry ganache and vanilla custard. 

Chocolate Dream

black bottom cake (chocolate cake marbled with cheesecake and chocolate chips) filled and frosted with chocolate buttercream

Raspberry Almond

almond cake filled with raspberry jam and raspberry buttercream.

Chocolate Funfetti

chocolate funfetti cake filled with chocolate funfetti buttercream.

Caramel Apple

cinnamon cake filled with caramel and house made apple pie filling, frosted with caramel buttercream.

BMT Signature
Cakes

Funfetti

4 layers of funfetti cake filled with funfetti buttercream, frosted with white buttercream, and rolled in rainbow sprinkles

Buckeye

3 layers of chocolate cake filled with peanut butter buttercream and crushed Reese’s cups, frosted with chocolate ganache, and topped with chocolate drip

Chocolate Salted Caramel

3 layers of chocolate cake filled with caramel and salted caramel buttercream, frosted with slated caramel buttercream, and topped with chocolate drip

Lemon Blueberry

3 layers of lemon blueberry cake filled with lemon curd, frosted with white buttercream

Strawberries and Cream

3 layers of vanilla cake filled with strawberry jam, vanilla custard, and strawberry buttercream, frosted with white buttercream

Classic Carrot

3 layers of carrot cake filled and frosted with cream cheese frosting

Cookies and Cream

3 layers of cookies and cream cake filled with cookies and cream buttercream and crushed Oreos, frosted with more cookies and cream buttercream

Hummingbird

3 layers of pineapple, banana, pecan cake filled and frosted with cream cheese frosting

S'mores

chocolate graham cake filled with graham crackers, marshmallow buttercream, and chocolate ganache, frosted with toasted meringue. 

Macarons

View Menu

Cupcakes

View Menu

Cakes

View Menu

Wedding

View Menu

Walk-ins

View Menu

Breakfast

View Menu

Baking Hours

Walk-In and Curbside
Available

Tuesday-Friday
9am-5pm

Saturday
8am-3pm

234-254-4005

Location

16 S Main St,
Poland, OH
44514