Christmas Treats

Order Online

Order Online

Shop Now

Cakes for any occasion

View Menu

Treat Yourself

View Menu

Services

Our Baking Services

Macarons

View Menu

Cupcakes

View Menu

Cakes

View Menu

Wedding Cakes

View Menu

Walk-ins

View Menu

Breakfast

View Menu

About BMT

Hello! My name is Gabriele Barnhizer, and I own and operate Bake Me Treats with my husband, Adam. We love what we do and are so excited to be a part of the small business scene here in Youngstown, Ohio.

I have dreamed of opening a bakery here in Poland since I fell in love with baking in grade school. My dream was realized in 2015 when I …

Full Bio

Customer Reviews

Our cake for our sons first birthday was so perfect! I was so happy I went with a local bakery that makes his cake so absolutely amazing! I will be dreaming of that cake for days! Even pickier family members loved it! It was delicious and the decoration was spot on. I couldn’t have been any happier!

A M A Z I N G!! Finally tried this bakery in our neighborhood and so glad we did. The brownies were absolutely delicious and the peanut butter cake is out of this world. beautiful presentation. Looking forward to trying all the other wonderful delights.
– Kelly B.
The almond cupcakes are delicious! I’ll have to try the macaroons on my next visit.
– Jean M.

Awesome macarons! So much flavor packed into them! Yum!
– Karen P.

Hands down the best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had.
– Emily Y.
Some of the best desserts in town, but the sleeper hit is the bagel sandwiches.
– Robby Y.
Amazing treats – cupcakes, macaroons, cakes, everything they make! And awesome people. Support this great local, small business.
– Tom W.

Baking Hours

Walk-In and Curbside
Available

Tuesday-Friday
9am-5pm

Saturday
8am-3pm

234-254-4005

Location

16 S Main St,
Poland, OH
44514

View in maps